Mortgage Refinancing That Nearly Cost Me $370,000

By Pinyo, on September 18, 2007

I mentioned previously that I made many financial mistakes in the past. One of the more serious ones was refinancing my mortgage from 30 years to 15 years in 2003 (about 4 years after I purchased my home). On the surface, I did a brilliant job of saving nearly $97,000 in interest expenses and ending my mortgage 11 years sooner.

Amortization Calculator

Here is the catch, if I invested the $4,000 refinancing expenses and the $288 monthly payments into an S&P 500 Index Fund. I might have $467,505 after 26 years (assuming a 10% CAGR). So, I am really looking at a $370,588 loss.

In addition, there are other factors that hurt me:

• Inflation — Assuming a 2% inflation rate, a dollar on year 30 will be worth about 56 cents in 1998. Thus, inflation helps people with long-term mortgage. With a shorter mortgage, I gave up some of that advantage. For instance, a dollar on year 30 will be worth about 70 cents in 1998.
• Tax deduction for mortgage interest – Lower interest expenses means less tax deduction. I gave up about 25% of $97,000 (or $24,000 in tax savings).

Fortunately, there are factors that help (or can help) me also:

• Catch up investment — When I paid off my mortgage, I can invest $1,427 into an S&P 500 Index Fund and I might have $350,000 in 11 years.
• Capital Gains Tax and Fund Distributions — I do not have to worry about capital gains tax and yearly taxes for interest, dividend, and distributions. Capital gains can amount to about $70,000 (15% of $467,505).
• Discipline to invest — To get $467,505, I have to invest $288 every month without touching that money. That is a big assumption.
• Interest payment savings and owning the house sooner is guaranteed!

After all these factors, I think I am all right (extremely lucky to be, since I did not consider everything discussed here). However, this example does demonstrate a few important points:

• Making prepayment or refinancing may not be a good choice.
• Interest payment saving is not the only factor.
• Cash flow, things we can do with the extra money, tax implications, and inflation are important factors.

In general, I can conclude two rules of thumb:

• Refinancing only make sense if the interest rate on the original loan is significantly higher AND you plan to live in the same house long enough to offset refinancing expenses.
• Making prepayment only make sense if your interest rate is approaching 8.5% (S&P 30-year historical performance is 12.41%, therefore, I use a conservative investment performance of 10% minus 15% capital gains tax, or 8.5% net)

Looking for more great posts about mortgage prepayment and refinancing?

• Get Rich Slowly, Ask the Readers: Is It Better to Invest or to Prepay a Mortgage?
• Free Money Finance, Should You Prepay Your Mortgage or Invest Instead?
• Foo Bar and Grill, Extra mortgage payments versus taxable investing
• Five Cent Nickel, More Thoughts About Refinancing Our Mortgage

Read more about

Get free updates

    via Twitter
    via Facebook
    via RSS or Email

Share this article

• 
• 
• 
• 
• Share

Pinyo is the brain behind Moolanomy personal finance blog and a few other web sites. If you like this article, please subscribe for free daily email updates.

All posts by Pinyo

Please share your comment:

Comment Rules: Constructive criticism is welcomed. Please use your PERSONAL name or initials and not your business name or URL, as the latter comes off like spam and I'll most likely delete your comment. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation! Here's our comment policy and guidelines.

2 blogs that link to this article:

If your trackback does not show in 24 hours, please resend to this trackback URI.

1. This Week in Review - Oktoberfest Edition | Cash Money Life
2. My Mortgage Dilemma - Prepay or Invest : A Penny Closer